Depending on the lie, wind, elevation, and how I'm hitting on any given day, I use a strong 56, a medium PW, or occasionally a soft 9 iron from 105 yards, though I admit that sometimes it comes down to a gut feeling or a confidence thing...
I see your point(s). Even the "standard" shot can be played many ways.
I guess some other questions would be: Is there a club that fits between the PW (which is 45 degrees, I think) and the 56? Should I be thinking about a 52?
Grip down on the PW and hit the same shot you did before...gripping down to the shaft will take 5 yards off easily. Don't step on the SW because you'll pull the shot every time.
I carry a gap wedge so at 105 yds it's a 3/4 Gap Wedge. If I didn't carry the gap wedge I would choose my pitching wedge over my sand wedge for the shot. I would grip down on a PW with a 3/4 backswing.
I find that when it comes to wedge shots I'm more accurate when I overclub, grip down, and 3/4 swing it versus underclubbing and swinging hard at it. The other problem with high lofted wedges is that the harder you swing the higher they fly, which can leave you short of the target.
If I absolutely had to hit the sand wedge, I would play the ball a little back in my stance and make sure my hands lead the clubface at impact. This basically delofts the club helping keep the trajectory down.
I find that when it comes to wedge shots I'm more accurate when I overclub, grip down, and 3/4 swing it versus underclubbing and swinging hard at it. The other problem with high lofted wedges is that the harder you swing the higher they fly, which can leave you short of the target.
I have a 51* Mizuno wedge that is currently in my bag. I'll probably go to a 52* Gap Wedge next time I buy one to better fill in between my PW and SW. Or I guess I could have my current wedge loft bent 1*
I have to agree with most of these guys. grip down on the pw take an easy 3/4 shot. I always get better results when i take a little off my gap wedge than when i try and muscle the sw in there.